BBC News

Trump's doctor says he's in excellent health - but are US presidents' health checks a PR exercise?

May 30, 2026 · Unknown · Original Source

Is the Presidential Physical Exam More About Public Relations Than Medicine?

"Are there any health concerns the American public should be aware of, Mr. President?" Following his annual medical examination, then-81-year-old Joe Biden, the oldest U.S. president in history, offered a lighthearted response: "Well, they think I look too young."

The health of the U.S. president is among the most scrutinized aspects of the office, given that the individual holds one of the most powerful positions globally. This intense focus on medical records has evolved into a uniquely American phenomenon. In the modern era, every president has made the brief trip from the White House to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for routine physicals. However, these examinations serve a dual purpose: they are not merely medical procedures but also tools for political messaging.

Dr. Matt Dallek, a political historian at George Washington University, explains that "Americans historically have wanted masculine presidents, vigorous presidents." Consequently, the physical exam allows a president to visibly demonstrate their vitality, thereby projecting an aura of political strength. Donald Trump, who is approaching his 80th birthday, has made this demonstration of vigor a central component of his presidential image.

Following his recent annual exam, the White House issued a memo on Friday from the president’s physician. The doctor stated that Trump is in "excellent health" and possesses "strong cardiac, pulmonary, neurological and overall physical function," declaring him "fully fit to carry out all duties of the commander-in-chief and head of state." Despite this positive assessment, the physician advised the president to lose weight and increase his exercise regimen.

Nevertheless, a clean bill of health from the presidential physician has its limitations. There is no legal mandate for presidents to disclose their medical records; they are protected by the same health privacy laws that apply to all other Americans.

A History of Concealment

Prior to the television age, it was significantly easier for presidents to obscure health issues. In 1919, President Woodrow Wilson suffered a severe stroke that left him largely incapacitated for the remainder of his term, effectively forcing his wife to make decisions on his behalf for over a year. His physician and other staff members successfully covered up the extent of his condition. Similarly, while the public was generally aware that President Franklin D. Roosevelt suffered from polio-induced paralysis, the White House minimized his reliance on a wheelchair until his death in 1945.

According to Jacob Appel, a medical ethicist at New York’s Mount Sinai Hospital and a historian of presidential health, transparency regarding regular physicals did not begin until the 1960s during Lyndon B. Johnson’s presidency in the Cold War era. Appel noted that in the 1970s, President Gerald Ford pushed to make some of his medical data public, despite objections from his own doctor.

"I feel fit as a fiddle. Getting healthier every day," Ford told reporters after his 1976 check-up, adding that he swam daily to maintain his fitness.

In contrast, President Ronald Reagan did not announce his Alzheimer’s diagnosis until five years after leaving office, sparking widespread speculation about his mental acuity during his second term.

The Limits of Transparency

Appel suggests that the public should be skeptical of these releases. "If I were the public, I would ignore that information [released by the White House] entirely," he told the BBC. "The president can cherry pick what looks good, and what doesn't look good."

Furthermore, many presidential check-up reports highlight minor, mundane issues. For instance, a 1996 New York Times report on Bill Clinton’s annual exam noted that doctors had removed a precancerous skin lesion from the tip of his nose. The following year, Clinton was recommended to use hearing aids.

In the highly polarized U.S. political climate, politicians have little incentive to reveal potential vulnerabilities. Additionally, presidential health is considered a matter of national security. "Anything we released to the American public will also be known by the Russian secret service, Chinese government, and adversaries," Appel highlighted.